AI Feedback
In the app: AI → Advanced → Feedback
Needs the 'Moderate AI Feedback' permission.
AI Feedback is the review queue for what your team writes about the AI's drafts and replies: why they rejected a draft, why they rewrote one, and why they gave a reply a thumbs down. Here you approve or dismiss each comment. It covers the whole organization.
What lands on this page
Only feedback that carries a written comment appears here. There are three kinds, each with its own label:
- "Rejection": a teammate rejected an AI draft in a conversation and wrote down why.
- "Rewrite": a teammate changed an AI draft before sending it and wrote down why. The label "…% rewritten" says how much of the draft was changed.
- "Thumbs down": a teammate gave an AI reply or draft a thumbs down. A thumbs down always needs a comment.
A rejection or rewrite without a comment does not appear in this queue. A thumbs up normally has no comment and stays out too. If a thumbs up carries a comment, it appears on the unfiltered tabs with the misleading label "Thumbs down"; choosing the "Thumbs down" type filter excludes it.
Whether Squid asks your team for a reason when they reject or rewrite a draft is set under Settings → AI Feedback. The "Feedback settings" link at the top right opens that page; it is shown to people with the 'Edit AI Config' permission.
Tabs and filters
- Tabs: "Pending" (not reviewed yet, the tab the page opens on), "Approved", "Dismissed" and "All".
- Type: "All types", "Rejections", "Rewrites" or "Thumbs down".
- Store: "All stores" or one store.
The list is newest first, 25 items per page, with "Previous" and "Next" when there are more. When the filters leave nothing, the page says "Nothing matches these filters" with a "Clear filters" link. An empty "Pending" tab shows "Nothing waiting for review".
The list always covers every store of the organization, also for a teammate whose access is limited to certain stores.
A feedback item
Each item shows:
- its kind and its status: "pending", "approved" or "dismissed";
- who wrote it, the store it came from, and when, in your own timezone;
- the comment your teammate wrote;
- "Show draft": opens the "AI draft" as the AI wrote it next to the "Final sent text", the reply your teammate sent in the end. For a rejection the second box says "Draft was rejected; no reply sent"; for other feedback without a sent reply it shows a dash;
- "Open conversation": opens the conversation in the Inbox, when the feedback is linked to one;
- once reviewed: who approved or dismissed it, and when.
Approve and dismiss
"Approve" marks the comment as trusted. "Dismiss" marks it as not to be used.
Both take effect at once and record your name and the time. On the "Pending", "Approved" and "Dismissed" tabs the item leaves the list you are looking at and moves to the other tab; on "All" it stays and shows its new status.
A decision can be reversed. An approved item still has a "Dismiss" button and a dismissed item still has an "Approve" button. There is no way to set an item back to "pending" from this page. An item returns to "pending" by itself, and its decision is cleared, when the teammate changes their rating or comment afterwards; a thumbs down changed into a thumbs up leaves the queue if its comment is cleared, but remains on the unfiltered tabs if a comment is kept.
Neither button deletes anything, tells the teammate who wrote the comment, or changes the conversation.
What approving changes
Feedback is read in two places: by the AI Builder when you ask it about the quality of the AI's replies, and by the insights shown for a config set. Nothing on this page changes a prompt or the AI's behaviour by itself. A prompt only changes when someone edits and activates it.
What those two places may read depends on one setting, "Require approval before feedback reaches the AI Builder", under Settings → AI Feedback:
- Off (the default): everything except dismissed feedback can be read, pending feedback included. Approving then usually changes nothing; if the approval setting cannot be read, only approved feedback is read. Dismissing removes the comment from what is read.
- On: only approved feedback can be read. This also applies to feedback that was collected before the setting was switched on.
Dismissed feedback is never read, whatever the setting.
The setting covers the written comments, the draft examples that go with them and the count of thumbs-down replies. Counts of how often drafts were approved, edited or rejected are not affected by approving or dismissing.